Archdiocese Announces Three More Catholic School Closures in Hudson Valley, NYC

John Jordon • March 18, 2026

NEW YORK—Following up on last month’s announcement of seven Catholic school closures in the New York metro region, the Superintendent of Schools Office for the Archdiocese of New York has reported three additional school closures—one in Westchester County, one in Orange County and another in Manhattan.


The three schools to close at the end of the current academic year are the Incarnation School in Manhattan, Sacred Heart School in Hartsdale, and Most Precious Blood School in Walden.


Two additional schools will undergo campus consolidations. The St. Anthony-St. Paul School in Nanuet/Valley Cottage will consolidate from two locations to one campus at St. Anthony Parish in Nanuet, and Transfiguration School in Manhattan, which was announced earlier this year by the parish and school, will consolidate from three locations to two sites.

“These decisions were made after extensive reflection, study, and prayer, as we face significant challenges that make it impossible to continue our mission at these locations,” Superintendent of Schools Office for the Archdiocese of New York Sr. Mary Grace Walsh wrote in a March 16th letter to pastors, principals, and school leaders. “It is our hope that all students will continue their Catholic school education in one of our other Catholic schools. Principals and enrollment teams will work with families in the months ahead to ensure a smooth transition.”

The closures are part of the Archdiocese’s ongoing School Renewal process. Last month, the Archdiocese of Brooklyn announced seven Catholic school closures this June: Sacred Heart Catholic Academy, Cambria Heights; St. Bartholomew Catholic Academy in Elmhurst; St. Nicholas of Tolentine Catholic Academy in Jamaica; Incarnation Catholic Academy in Queens Village; St. Thomas the Apostle Catholic Academy in Woodhaven; St. Elizabeth Catholic Academy in Ozone Park and Our Lady of Trust Catholic Academy in Canarsie.


The February closures were promoted by severe declines in student enrollment.


Among the key initiatives of the ongoing School Renewal process is strengthening Catholic identity and faith formation and expansion of STREAM programs. Seven schools will become STREAM education centers (Science, Technology, Religion, Engineering, Arts, and Math), providing hands-on, faith-centered learning experiences. Other components of the process include collaboration with the Latino Engagement Institute through the University of Notre Dame that will expand to reach more schools and families, expansion of Special Education services and planned capital investments.

Headshot of John Dolgetta, Esq. next to the Legal Corner Monthly logo and the HGAR logo against a brown background.
By John Dolgetta, Esq. March 18, 2026
For real estate brokers, the new law may significantly improve transaction predictability.
A wooden gavel rests on a round block in a softly lit, out-of-focus courtroom setting.
By John Jordon March 16, 2026
NYSAR stated: “Upon filing the appeal, the decision is stayed until the New York State Court of Appeals publishes a decision…”
By Dr. Jermaine Meadows March 12, 2026
Approximately 123,000 households rely on Section 8 vouchers to help pay rent, and the program remains a central tool for addressing housing affordability and homelessness.
By Real Estate In-Depth March 12, 2026
If demand picks up notably in the coming months and outpaces supply growth, home prices will inevitably rise.
By John Jordan March 11, 2026
“HGAR will continue to advocate for policies that promote housing opportunity, protect property rights, and support a fair, transparent, and functional housing market for everyone.”
By Alexander Roithmayr March 2, 2026
One of the clearest themes that emerged from our testimony was that the biggest hurdle facing first-time buyers is not necessarily the monthly payment, but the upfront costs required to enter the market.
More